Cicero IN Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Just 30 miles north of Indianapolis sits the town of Cicero, Indiana, nestled along the shoreline of the Morse Reservoir. For its approximately 4,800 residents, as well as neighbors from throughout Hamilton County, Cicero is a family-friendly recreational haven that offers everything from boating to swimming to golf.

In Cicero, homebuyers will find a mixture of older, well-kept homes and newer suburban properties surrounding the Morse Reservoir. The man-made lake, built more than 50 years ago to provide a water supply to Indianapolis, has 35 miles of shoreline that offer waterfront living to the residents of Cicero and adjacent Noblesville, which surrounds the reservoir’s southern tip.

Read more

Cicero October 17, 2018
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
18 Properties Found. Showing 1-12
Sort By:

Newcomers have flocked to Cicero in recent years, with its population increasing by more than 10 percent between the 2000 and 2010 federal censuses. They have been drawn, in part, by the top-flight Hamilton Heights School Corporation, where the district’s leaders have set the goal of ranking as one of the state’s best in terms of student achievement, striving to best prepare its graduates for success in an increasingly global work world. The school district uses innovative teaching methods in its quest for excellence, and it also motivates students to realize their potential and encourages them to serve their community and treat each other with respect.

A top-flight school district might attract potential residents to look at homes in the community, but once they explore Cicero, home shoppers are hooked by its affordability, beauty and tranquility. Because people recognize the desirability of Cicero and continue to move into the town, real estate in the community is coveted.

In terms of homes for sale, the supply in Cicero ranges from maintenance-free condominiums to dream homes with all of today’s most-wanted amenities. In all, more than 600 houses in Cicero sit on the water, have access to it or offer a view of the glistening blue water. Along the reservoir, there are public docks and a boat ramp for residents to take their boats into the water, and even a place to fill their boats up with gas.

The area offers so much more than boating, however. The highly touted Bear Slide Golf Club in Cicero has received high rankings from Golf Digest, and it has been named one of the Top 10 public golf courses in Cicero. The first nine holes feature Scottish-style links, with the final half offering traditional golf. A few dozen golf courses sit within a 20-mile radius of Cicero as well. Just south along the reservoir in Noblesville are notable family destinations. Among them are Morse Park and Beach, a 23-acre park filled with summer fun, such as a disc golf course, a beach, picnic grounds, fishing and softball leagues. Families also join the Harbour Trees Golf & Beach Club, which has a fitness center, golf court, tennis courts, swimming pool, and dining.

Speaking of eating, locals flock to Wolfies Grill, a waterfront restaurant with a menu to please both adults and kids.

Many people come to Cicero because of the outdoor lifestyle and the ability to put their boat in the water on any sunny day. Still, home shoppers should consult with the experts at Talk to Tucker about the specifics of the reservoir should they want to live on the waterfront. The professionals working in Cicero will be able to offer advice about the best parts of the reservoir, including where the shallow areas are.

Living in Cicero, Indiana, has all the advantages a homebuyer could want. Cicero is a small town with lots to keep both the kids and their parents entertained. Still, it’s an easy commute to job centers in Kokomo and Indianapolis, and close enough to take advantage of the big-city amenities, such as the cultural centers and professional sports of Indianapolis.

If Cicero fits what you are looking for in a community, call the professionals at Talk to Tucker to find a real estate agent who can help you find a home to meet your needs. Tell us what you are looking for in a residence in terms of size and location, and our agents will locate a variety of homes for you to look at. With their knowledge of Cicero, our agents will steer you toward just the right property for your family.

Talk to Tucker also offers a variety of other services that you will need as you move to Cicero. Our agents can help you arrange financing, purchase homeowners and title insurance, and secure a home warranty; they will support your move from start to finish.