Homes for Sale in Otterbein, Indiana

Uniquely perched across the county lines of Benton and Tippecanoe Counties, the quaint town of Otterbein promises a quintessential small-town experience just miles away from Lafayette. Locals take tremendous pride in their little community as evidenced in its well-maintained downtown area, quaint parks, and the general sense of contentment that seems to hang in the air. These neighborly streets are perfect for a quiet stroll and enjoying the simple pleasures of simple living.

This makes Otterbein the ideal community for those who work in nearby Lafayette, just 15 miles away by way of US-52. If you work in Otterbein, which despite its small size is not short of its own economic amenities, Lafayette offers a thriving cultural and arts scene, not to mention a tremendous nightlife. When an urban escape from your small town life is needed, Lafayette is definitely close enough for Otterbein residents.

If you've set your sights on Otterbein, you've made a great choice in exploring your housing options. Our Otterbein relators would love to introduce you further to this attractive community. We delight in turning what can be frustrating process into one that is fluid, fun, and rewarding.

Read more

Otterbein October 22, 2018
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
9 Properties Found.
Sort By:

Otterbein Area Homes

Homes in Otterbein come in a variety of styles and can be found in several unique neighborhoods in town. You might prefer to see homes further out from the center of town where there is more privacy along stunning natural beauty. Or perhaps you prefer to live closer to Otterbein’s quaint downtown community, which is home to several small shops, parks, and the town's prized college.

In either case you're likely to find classic, older homes big on cozy qualities as well as newer developments with modern designs and spaces. If there is a specific housing style that you prefer, neighborhood aspects that you favor, or if you have commuting concerns, be sure to mention those needs to your Tucker realtor in Otterbein who can narrow down housing options based on your preferences.

Shopping and Dining

When it comes to basic necessities and needs, residents of Otterbein can find most of what they need in town. Despite its small size, you'll find grocery stores and general stores, specialty shops and boutiques, and similar establishments. For a quick bite out, several dining establishments can also be found in town.

For broader commercial choices, you only need to look 15 miles to the east where Lafayette awaits. The city includes three downtown districts, each with its own unique collection of commercial offerings. Highlighting the shopping experience is the Arts & Market District, which is home to many quaint shops and specialty boutiques.

It also hosts a seasonal farmers’ market, offering handmade crafts, and fresh local foods. Chauncey Village, which lies on the outskirts of Purdue University, features the kind of grub one might expect in a college town including numerous pubs, pizza parlors, and burger joints. Not to be outdone, the Riverfront District boasts many shopping and dining options along the scenic Wabash River including many delicious ethnic options. Adding to the fun, West Lafayette is home to the Tippecanoe Mall, the region's largest mall.

Culture and Entertainment

Otterbein residents love their town and love to show it off in a variety of ways including using their well-kept streets and parks to celebrate with a variety of cultural and community events. This includes their chief yearly festival, the Otterbein Street Festival, held in their downtown area. This famous festival features craft and food vendors, live entertainment, and games.

For a little more varied excitement, Otterbein residents aren't afraid to make use of beautiful Lafayette as a cultural playground. The city offers several venues for live music and theater as well as an excellent football stadium, which often plays host to cultural events. In fact Lafayette is home to many festivals throughout the year that celebrate music, food, and the arts.

Due to its gorgeous neighborhoods and significant, historical landmarks, Lafayette is widely considered a walking city, perfect for a leisurely stroll. Among these neighborhoods are three that considered "downtown." Chauncey, due to its proximity to Purdue University, features a collegiate air and a boisterous nightlife and is an entertainment destination for students, alumni, and visitors. The Riverfront District along the Wabash River is home to numerous landmark sites including the John Meyers Pedestrian Bridge, Riehle Plaza, and Tapawingo Park. Finally, the Arts & Market District is known for its plethora of galleries and museums.

The sports entertainment scene is dominated by Purdue University, which boasts numerous NCAA programs and an excellent football facility in Ross-Ade Stadium. And golfers will love taking advantage the many golf clubs and golf courses available to them as cyclists and runners will enjoy the bike paths and parks that wind their way through the city.

Careers and Industry

Within the town manufacturing and agriculture are major sources of employment. Otterbein features an industrial park and surroundings that include many fertile farms.

Many residents take advantage of living in Otterbein to work in nearby Lafayette, which features a diverse and stable economy, bolstered by the economic behemoth that is Purdue University. Naturally, education is a major employment sector but so are the many of the businesses and enterprises that exist due to their ties to the university. Purdue's 40,000 students added to Lafayette's already large population also means many jobs in entertainment, retail, and dining. Finally, Lafayette features a well-regarded regional healthcare services system that also means plenty of jobs in medicine.


Students living in Otterbein attend schools in the Benton Community School Corporation. While based out of nearby Oxford, young learners have the benefit of sticking close to home thanks to centrally located Otterbein Elementary School.

Following their primary school education, Otterbein's children come together with other children from neighboring towns to form a strong, collaborative learning community at Benton Central Junior-Senior High School. There they enjoy an expanded educational program designed to challenge and to develop strong critical thinkers and socially responsible young adults. At all grade levels, the school offers many sciences and fine arts courses to ensure a well-rounded education as well as technology integration into the learning plan.