Homes for Sale in Rolling Prairie, Indiana

This aptly-named town has a surprising number of advantages for its tiny size. So named because of the gentle plains that extend into the distance, Rolling Prairie is a peaceful retreat from the city just outside of the Chicago metropolitan area. It’s a popular place for commuting professionals and families who want access a little peace and quiet and all the bounties that nature has to offer without giving up access to big-city excitement. Our Rolling Prairie realtors are big fans of this community and would love the chance to show you the charms of this well-kept secret.

The close proximity to Chicago isn’t the only thing this community has going for it. It’s also right on the doorstep of Lake Michigan and all the sport, leisure, and nature opportunities that location suggests. And if you were interested in a more personal lake experience, our realtors can likely accommodate you.

You see, the area around Rolling Prairie is filled with many lakes. All the lakes are an excellent complement to the other natural wonders of the area and likely the reason properties around Rolling Prairie are so valued. If you are interested in becoming one of the new and loyal residents of this little town, we hope you’ll call Tucker. Our realtors can tell you everything you need to know about buying homes for sale in Rolling Prairie.

Read more

Rolling Prairie October 23, 2018
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
20 Properties Found. Showing 1-12
Sort By:

Rolling Prairie Homes

You’ll find wonderful homes in Rolling Prairie including many that suggest the rich history this town has had since the early 1800s. The homes around here are often large, and many come on large lots that give you, your children, and your pets plenty of room to breathe. If you were interested in building your own home, this area is a perfect fit. There are still plenty of wonderful lots in and around the town.

Because of the prime location and the professionals who have made this region their home, you may find that some of the homes here can be prohibitive to some family budgets. However, plenty of affordable options do make it to the real estate market, and our realtors can help you find the right home. They can also monitor the market to let you know when something in your budget is listed.

If the access to lakes excites you, Rolling Prairie and the area around it may offer you some of the best options in the entire state of Indiana. There are plenty of properties in the nearby area that are either lakeside to the larger lakes or feature completely private lakes. Let our realtors know if a personal lake interests you, and we may be able to find just the right option.

Shopping and Dining

Rolling Prairie doesn’t have much in the way of its own shopping or restaurants, but that seems to be by design. You won’t have any trouble finding a bite to eat close to town and just a little further out (not even 15 minutes by car in some cases), you’ll find so many options that you’ll never get bored.

The best shopping and dining in that tight radius is the city of La Porte. There are more than a handful of restaurants and shopping destinations in La Porte, and many of them are locally owned. Not much farther in the other direction is New Carlisle, which hosts plenty of its own charming options. If you’re willing to drive up to 20 minutes away, you can make your way to Michigan City. This happening city on the shore of Lake Michigan and right next to Indiana Dunes State Park has everything you need.

The even larger cities of South Bend and Chicago are also right on your doorstep. South Bend is barely half an hour away, and at just over an hour to its downtown area, Chicago is within the perfect distance for a leisurely day trip. Between those two magnificent cities, you aren’t denied a world-class shopping or dining experience. It’s all here from the best of Midwestern grub to some the ritziest restaurants and galleries the Unites States has to offer.

Culture and Entertainment

Rolling Prairie doesn’t have much in the way of its own cultural institutions. However, its placement means finding all the culture and entertainment you could possibly want isn’t a challenge. Whether you’re interested in what the outdoors have to offer or in the thrills of big-city excitement, you have more to enjoy here than you could take advantage of in a lifetime.

If you’re interested in outdoorsy fun, particularly when water is involved, you’re never going to be short on options. Lake Michigan is naturally the star attraction in this region, offering unlimited options for fishing, boating, and many other hobbies. Likewise, many of the smaller lakes around the town are designated conservation areas or incorporated into parks you can visit with your family.

Dune Acres State Park is the largest park in the area, which is located near Michigan City, covers nearly 2000 acres of lakeside nature. Because of the ideal terrain in the area, there are also dozens of golf courses within a short drive of Rolling Prairie.

When it comes to the big-city lights, they’re all around you. Chicago is a world-class city that offers you more in the way of entertainment than most other cities in the world. Each neighborhood is filled with eateries, pubs, museums, and other vibrant expressions of culture. It may even be impossible to attend all the festivals and events you might want to because so many of them are happening at the same time.

Careers and Industry

There are almost no businesses directly in Rolling Prairie. Many of the people in this community prefer to commute to one of the other nearby communities such as La Porte and South Bend, which feature all kinds of businesses. Because of the local trains and interstate system, the option of working in the Chicago area is also viable.


The schools in town are managed by the New Prairie United School Corporation. This respected corporation provides a wonderful education to the children in its care and is frequently recognized by the state for the quality of that care. Several elementary schools are in town including Olive Township Elementary School, Prairie View Elementary School, and Rolling Prairie Elementary School. Further out but still accessible are New Prairie Middle/High School.

Get Pre-Approved

Use our online application to get pre-approved today.

Tucker Blog

Stay up to date on what is happening in the real estate market. Read the latest Market Watch on our blog.