Realtor Header
Susan Martello
Susan Martello Broker
10 North First Street
Zionsville, IN 46077

Download the Tucker App!

Susan Martello Broker

Susan Martello, Associate Broker

Associate Broker, Attorney at law

Your home is quite possibly the largest investment that you have.  In today’s market, you need a real estate expert that you can trust and a personal advocate to guide you through the buying and selling process.  As your real estate expert, I offer you a unique service because I worked as an attorney for 10 years before joining F.C. Tucker Company.  From my legal practice, I have developed negotiating skills that will help you get the best price for your home, and I pay attention to detail necessary for a smooth transaction.  I am committed to helping you with all of your real estate needs whether that entails finding or building your dream home, looking for your first home, downsizing, relocating to another city, or anything in between!  

If you are planning to sell, please contact me for a free market analysis of your home and a marketing plan that will set your home apart from the others. I also offer home staging tips to help your home sell faster.  If you are in the market to buy, I will work closely with you to find your next home that meets your needs.  I will walk you through the buying and selling process every step of the way and make it an enjoyable experience for you.

Achievements and Education

  • Judicial Law Clerk to the Indiana Supreme Court
  • Juris Doctorate, Magna Cum Laude, Valparaiso University Law School
    • Member of the Valparaiso Law Review Board
    • Studied in Cambridge, England for a semester
  • Bachelor of Science, Indiana University-Kelley School of Business

Professional Credentials and Affiliations

  • Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, Indiana
  • Licensed Attorney, Indiana
  • Graduate, F. C. Tucker School of Real Estate
  • Graduate, Professional Sales Academy, Tucker University
  • Real Estate Continuing Education Courses
  • National Association of REALTORS®
  • Indiana Association of REALTORS®
  • Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®

Personal Background

I have lived in Indianapolis for 15 years and have resided in Zionsville for the past 7 years with my husband Scott Martello and our dog Sherman. We are active with the Humane Society and are committed to care for and protect our pets. In my spare time, I enjoy practicing yoga and pilates, traveling, and learning Spanish.


Custom Home, Dream Home, Executive Home, Existing Home, First-Time Buyers, Luxury Homes, New Construction, New Home, Relocation, Residential, Retirement.

I look forward to putting my experience and passion for real estate to work for you!

By Jacqueline Hash
I had worked with a few realtors briefly before meeting Susan, but none of them had the drive or sheer love of real estate as Susan does. Susan made it a lot more enjoyable from the start. She promptly and completely answered all questions and concerns I had, and was willing to search out additional  information to ensure I could make the most informed decisions. Her legal back ground and 24/7 work ethic makes her an amazing realtor. If you are looking for a realtor who will answer your calls all times of day and night, seek out properties specifically to you specifications, and have your best interests at heart, then Susan is the realtor for you!  I also really appreciated her recommendations for people I could trust concerning getting a mortgage, home inspection, and even home repairs. Even after I moved  in and encountered a problem with the house, I contacted Susan and she was more than willing to help. It's comforting to know I have a realtor who is willing to help me even after closing. Thank you so much Susan for all your help and perseverance! Definitely one of a kind. 
By Sean McCarthy, Indianapolis, IN
I had the absolute pleasure of working with Susan Martello as my fiancée and I were searching for our first home. Knowing little about the home-buying process, we were in need of an agent that had deep knowledge and experience in the real estate market, and Susan was just that. Throughout the home-buying process, Susan was there every step of the way – from our first phone call with her to the day we closed on our first house. Her knowledge, coupled with her passion for helping people, gave us the perfect end product for which we were hoping. Susan was patient, determined, proactive and extremely professional, providing us with extensive market research that ultimately guided our final decision. Susan was also more than willing to go above and beyond, showing us countless homes, meeting with us on evening and weekends, participating in our inspection, answering questions thoroughly and quickly and even sending us a welcome package as we moved into our home.Perhaps the single greatest endorsement I could give to Susan is this: I would trust her again and again to assist us in the home-buying process. In addition, I would (and have) recommend her to anyone that is searching for a home – my friends and family included.