Jeffery Mathey


Shelly Walters Realty Group

About Me

Jeff specializes in First-Time Home Buyers, Investment Properties, Rentals & Property Management.

I am a full time Buyer’s Agent with the Shelly Walter’s Realty Group with the F. C. Tucker Company.  I enjoy working with clients to make an their home buying experience as pleasurable, easy and care and stress free as possible.  I enjoy the thrill of helping clients find their dream homes and this makes for a very rewarding career.  

I was born and raised in Chicago (yes, the actual city not a suburb) and I attended the University of Illinois Urbana Champaign where I graduated with a degree in Communications with an emphasis on marketing and advertising.  I offer tons of real world experience working in fields relating to home building such as construction, HVAC, plumbing and electrician.  I also have a background in financing, as I was a mortgage loan originator in the Chicago and surrounding area for a number of years.

I bring all of this knowledge and experience with me to ensure I can answer any questions you may have about the home buying experience, the home in general and anything you may want to change on any of the homes we see!  I truly want to make this the easiest and most memorable experience of your life!

My Recommendations

Very professional and honest. Good listener. We worked together to sell the home. Easy to work with and great marketing. All materials were top-notch & very well presented.  - Larry & Barbara C.
I worked with agent Jeffery Mathew for search of my 1st home in Carmel, IN. During the entire process from the search till the closure it was great working with him. He was extremely responsive and kept showing us houses as needed. Once we finalized our house he did help us a lot with all the  formalities and also kept us informed with all the process involved. He is very knowledgeable in terms of the things involved in the house and the improvement ideas. I would definitely recommend Jeff to all my friends and if needed have him for my next house.  - Advait & Neeta J.
As a buyer interested in investment rental properties, I worked with Jeffery Mathey at Shelly Walter's office, who specializes in these transactions. I was only in town for a week, and Jeffery showed me a large number of homes (20?) of which I eventually bought five. When one of the deals fell  through because of bad home inspection results, he helped me find another house remotely, by doing video walk-throughs. He handled all the paperwork promptly, and now handles the property management of the homes.  - Michael C.
Jeff has been hugely helpful for us. We are first time home buyers with no prior knowledge of any of the processes and he walked us through them step by step. Jeff is also very responsive with any questions we have. Jeff made the whole process fun and stress free for us. We would highly  recommend his expertise to anyone looking to buy a new home! - Brian & Shyann V.
Jeff did great throughout our entire home shopping/buying experience. He showed us lots of homes in several towns. He also helped us through some home buying snags along the way. Awesome patience and help...Thanks youJeff.  - Adam & Jill N.
Jeffery Mathey did a fine job. I bought a home locally and he knew a lot about the property. What he didn't know, he found out for me quickly. He provided me with names, lists of contractors, services I needed, ideas for solving problems I saw in the home and more. He stayed with me at one time  (when I was alone) while a repairman came to work on needed repairs. I appreciated that because I didn't know much about the repairs needed. Jeff gave me the help I needed, which made me feel more secure making a significant purchase like buying a home. I would recommend Jeff to any prospective buyer.  - AnnaMay M.


The Home Buying Process

Our Team

Meet Shelly Walters Realty Group

Team Member
Jeffery Mathey
Team Leader
Shelly Walters
Team Member
Lindsey Mathey
Team Member
Sharon Smith
Team Member
Devin Schoonover
Team Member
Jeremy North
Dec 11, 2018

Indy Adult Holiday Events

Dec 7, 2018

Best Places for Comfort Food in Indiana

Dec 5, 2018

Christmas Tree Farms in Indiana

Dec 4, 2018

Help Me, Help You, Help Me, Help Us… Or Something Like That

Nov 29, 2018

Hosting for the Holidays