• Min
    • $0+
    • $50k+
    • $75k+
    • $100k+
    • $150k+
    • $200k+
    • $250k+
    • $300k+
    • $350k+
    • $400k+
    • $450k+
    • $500k+
    • $750k+
  • All Beds x
    • Any
    • 1 +
    • 2 +
    • 3 +
    • 4 +
    • 5 +
    • 6 +
  • Residential xCondominiums x+1
    • Select All
    • Residential
    • Condominiums
    • Commercial Lease
    • Commercial
    • Lots / Acreage
    • Multi-Family
    • Farms/AgriculturalLand
    • Rental
    • Auction
  • Active xPending x+1
    • Select All
    • Active
    • Pending
    • Sold
  • ALL FILTERS
  • Save Search
Tucker Customer Care, REALTORĀ®/Broker, F. C. Tucker Company
Tucker Customer Care
Additional Phone (317) 954-4768
Email customerservice@talktotucker.com
F.C. Tucker Company

The house prices in Middletown are indeed dropping at the moment. There has been a decrease in price of $89,480.75. There are several factors that can cause a price drop. Higher mortgage rates, lower demand, prices of comparable properties can all cause the price of a house to drop.

The housing market and house prices in Middletown are going Down . The average house price is $276,950.00 and the average price per square feet is $124.89 per square feet. At the moment, the amount of homes listed is exactly 53 houses, with 10 with active status, 5 with pending status and 38 sold in Middletown.

The most popular place to buy a home in Middletown is 3301 - Henry - Fall Creek. 3301 - Henry - Fall Creek is where we have the most properties listed and there seems to be the most demand to buy a house. Some people love to live in the most popular areas of a city, and others prefer to live in an area that is less busy. Regardless of your preference, we have a vast variety of listings and agents to help you find a house in Middletown.

The average amount of property taxes you would have to pay for a home in Middletown is $1,530.00. It is important to consider property taxes when purchasing a home. Property taxes are tied to the value of the home. The more expensive the home is, the higher the taxes will be.

Properties in Middletown are staying listed for an average of 52 days. A good way to tell if you are in a buyer's or seller's market is to look at the average days on market for homes in the area. A low number of average days on market indicate a seller's market whereas a high number of average days on market indicate a buyer's market.

The last home listed in Middletown was 19615 minutes ago.

At the moment we have 1 open houses that you can visit.

The number of schools in Middletown is exactly 3 schools. An example of some names are Shenandoah Elementary School, Shenandoah High School, Shenandoah Middle School. Schools are an important consideration as you look for houses. The house you choose can determine the education your child receives.

The cost of the most expensive home in Middletown is $524,900.00. There are several reasons to consider buying an expensive home. They typically have great amenities, will be in great condition, and have plenty of space inside and outside of the home. Expensive real estate usually appreciates very fast, making it a good investment if you can afford it.

The cost of the cheapest home in Middletown is $65,000.00 . Buying a cheap house can have many benefits including keeping your payments low, allowing more room in your budget to customize or improve the house, as well as allowing you to pay of your mortgage faster.

The date of the oldest built home in Middletown in year 1890 and the newest built house is in year 2002.

The average size of properties in Middletown is 2405.8 sq.ft. , the biggest one being 4334 sq.ft. and the smaller being 840 sq.ft. . The size of your family and budget are important factors to consider when purchasing a home.

Middletown Homes for Sale

Homes for Sale in Middletown, Indiana

If you're in the market for a quality home in a small community big on virtues, Middletown is well worth your attention. This lovely Midwestern town features genuine appeal due to its shaded streets, pleasant lots, and inviting homes. Like many small towns in Indiana, good acquaintances are easy to come by with residents often meeting in its historic downtown district or congregating in one of its pristine parks. Rich nearby farmlands serve as a reminder that this is America's heartland.

But just because you're living the simple life, doesn’t mean you're completely cut off from modern conveniences when living in Middletown. Homeowners have easy access to Interstate 69, US-36, and State Road 67. These convenient corridors mean an easy drive to the cities of Anderson, Muncie, even Indianapolis. A Tucker agent can help you explore this pleasant housing market and decide if it is right for you.

 

Middletown Area Homes

Homes in Middletown run the gamut in terms of styles. Owing to the town's long history, home buyers can find older styles of architecture uncommon in today's market for those who enjoy the classics. Of course, more modern looks are plentiful as well. If you have a particular style in mind, let your Tucker realtor know, and they may be able to find something that suits your preferences in town. They can also help you narrow down other options such as whether you'd prefer a home closer to the town's center and its amenities or further outside of town where you can take the notion of peace and quiet to the extreme.

 

Shopping and Dining

Generally, living in Middletown means not having to travel out of town when it comes to basic shopping needs. Homeowners have the luxury of several locally owned stores to shop at, mostly located in the town's downtown district. This includes pharmacies, specialty stores, service shops, and even a supermarket. Likewise, the town offers several dining options, a mix of some family owned and some national franchises.

For more robust shopping options, the easiest commute is to Anderson, just over ten miles west of town. As a larger city, Anderson serves as a commercial hub for surrounding towns. Muncie is only a few miles further away to the east, and with a population twice that of Anderson, it offers an even more diverse and extensive experience. You'll find hopping commercial districts including an thriving downtown that hosts hundreds of shopping options. You'll also find more eclectic dining options in both Anderson and Muncie than what is offered in Middletown including ethnic options, grills, pizza parlors, cafes, and high-end establishments.

Although certainly more ambitious, Indianapolis to the southwest makes for an excellent day trip for those craving a metropolitan shopping excursion.

 

Culture and Entertainment

Like many of Indiana's small towns, Middletown comes with its own heritage and traditions including community events throughout the year. These often make use of the town's numerous parks as a backdrop, which are maintained in pristine condition by the town's Parks and Recreation Department. You'll also find paths for walking, running, and biking, often alongside gently flowing brooks and lined with benches and picnic areas. Historical buffs will also love strolling through the town's historic downtown.

Being advantageously close to both Anderson and Muncie, there are also several recreational outlets for Middletown residents. Anderson's famed racetrack, Anderson Speedway, is home to weekly racing events and hosts the annual Little 500. Other popular attractions include Mounds State Park and Hoosier Park Racing and Casino. Muncie is home to several art museums and theatres, highlighted by Ball State's 3,500-seat Emens Auditorium. Muncie also boasts a flourishing music scene and hosts several music festivals each year such as Muncie Gras and Muncie MusicFest.

What Middletown residents cannot find in Anderson or Muncie, they can surely find in Indianapolis to the southwest. Indianapolis is home of the Colts and the Pacers, and you can catch national concert tours, professional theater productions, or partake in the city's thriving nightlife.            

 

Careers and Industry

While the community around Middletown is rural and many of its residents work the farmland, numerous other economic options are available to those willing to make a short commute. With both Anderson and Muncie close by, jobs in just about every sector can be found. Outside of agriculture, the major players are healthcare, education, manufacturing, and retail. However, local developments and investments also mean positions available in small business and technology.

If you're looking to live in Middletown to take advantage of its commuting benefits, you've made a good choice. A Tucker realtor can work with you to find a home in town that makes sense for your commuting needs if that's a factor.

 

Schools

Public school education in Middletown is administered by the Shenandoah School Corporation. All three schools in the system are located in the south end of town along US-36.  Primary school students attend Shenandoah Elementary School where they are privy to a nurturing early learning environment that encourages parental involvement.

For Grades 7–8, students attend Shenandoah Middle School where they're provided with increased choices in their education during these important transitional years. Shenandoah High School rounds out the district. There, students enjoy a progressive curriculum designed to challenge and inspire. Advanced placement and vocational classes are offered along with a broad array of fine arts instruction. Numerous extracurricular programs including plenty of chances to contribute to the community are also available.

Middletown Neighborhoods

  • Henry County
  • Honey Creek
  • Honnold
  • Jacksons
  • Maple Hills
  • Summers
  • Wisehart
Tucker Customer Care, REALTORĀ®/Broker, F. C. Tucker Company
Tucker Customer Care
Additional Phone (317) 954-4768
Email customerservice@talktotucker.com
F.C. Tucker Company
Tucker Mortgage
Home Service
Relocating? Let us help
Legend
Map
Reset Map

Homes For Sale in Middletown, Indiana, IN

15 results
    • 1
    MiddletownIN47356976 High Street Middletown, IN 47356
    Pending
    976  High Street Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21946061

    $199,900

    On Site: 3 days

    976 High Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    F.C. Tucker/Prosperity
    MLS # 21946061
    Bedroom icon.4 BR
    Bathroom icon. 3 BA
    Square footage icon.2,402 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356-95418431 N Cherry Knoll Drive Middletown, IN 47356-9541
    Pending
    8431 N Cherry Knoll Drive Middletown, IN 47356-9541 | MLS 202334464

    $420,000

    On Site: 11 days

    8431 N Cherry Knoll Drive

    Middletown, IN, 47356-9541

    Courtesy of:

    F.C. Tucker / Prosperity
    MLS # 202334464
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.2,167 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356951 Locust Street Middletown, IN 47356
    951  Locust Street Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21943717

    $289,900

    On Site: 12 days

    951 Locust Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    Keller Williams Indy Metro NE
    MLS # 21943717
    Bedroom icon.5 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.2,738 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN473565863 W County Road 600 Middletown, IN 47356
    5863 W County Road 600  Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21944446

    $524,900

    On Site: 11 days

    5863 W County Road 600

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions
    MLS # 21944446
    Bedroom icon.4 BR
    Bathroom icon. 3 BA
    Square footage icon.4,011 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356606 N 12th Street Middletown, IN 47356
    Pending
    606 N 12th Street Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21944145

    $197,900

    On Site: 13 days

    606 N 12th Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions
    MLS # 21944145
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 1 BA
    Square footage icon.1,170 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356558 Central Avenue Middletown, IN 47356
    Pending
    558  Central Avenue Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21940323

    $129,900

    On Site: 35 days

    558 Central Avenue

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    eXp Realty, LLC
    MLS # 21940323
    Bedroom icon.2 BR
    Bathroom icon. 1 BA
    Square footage icon.1,772 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN473561403 Congress Street Middletown, IN 47356
    1403  Congress Street Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21936764

    $65,000

    On Site: 42 days

    1403 Congress Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    Golden Rule Realty, LLC
    MLS # 21936764
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 1 BA
    Square footage icon.840 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356118 N 7TH Street Middletown, IN 47356
    118 N 7TH Street Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 202327283

    $174,900

    On Site: 61 days

    118 N 7TH Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    Rhodes Realty
    MLS # 202327283
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.2,142 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356118 N 7th Street Middletown, IN 47356
    118 N 7th Street Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21935572

    $174,900

    On Site: 61 days

    118 N 7th Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    Rhodes Realty, LLC
    MLS # 21935572
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.2,622 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN473568431 N Cherry Knoll Drive Middletown, IN 47356
    Pending
    8431 N Cherry Knoll Drive Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21934896

    $420,000

    On Site: 12 days

    8431 N Cherry Knoll Drive

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    F.C. Tucker/Prosperity
    MLS # 21934896
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.4,334 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN473567263 N County Road 700 Middletown, IN 47356
    Pending
    7263 N County Road 700  Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21931457

    $625,000

    On Site: 76 days

    7263 N County Road 700

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    F.C. Tucker Company
    MLS # 21931457
    Bedroom icon.5 BR
    Bathroom icon. 5 BA
    Square footage icon.4,034 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN473561207 W Mill Street Middletown, IN 47356
    Pending
    1207 W Mill Street Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 202323820

    $159,900

    On Site: 84 days

    1207 W Mill Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    PPG Real Estate LLC
    MLS # 202323820
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.1,160 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356-1006508 N 5Th Street Middletown, IN 47356-1006
    Pending
    508 N 5Th Street Middletown, IN 47356-1006 | MLS 202320958

    $142,000

    On Site: 106 days

    508 N 5Th Street

    Middletown, IN, 47356-1006

    Courtesy of:

    Berkshire Hathaway Indiana Realty
    MLS # 202320958
    Bedroom icon.2 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.1,405 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN47356-93549646 W State Road 236 Road Middletown, IN 47356-9354
    9646 W State Road 236 Road Middletown, IN 47356-9354 | MLS 202301782

    $314,700

    On Site: 255 days

    9646 W State Road 236 Road

    Middletown, IN, 47356-9354

    Courtesy of:

    eXp Realty, LLC
    MLS # 202301782
    Bedroom icon.3 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.1,497 Sqft.
    MiddletownIN473568542 W Us Highway 36 Middletown, IN 47356
    8542 W Us Highway 36  Middletown, IN 47356 | MLS 21859991

    $264,000

    On Site: 489 days

    8542 W Us Highway 36

    Middletown, IN, 47356

    Courtesy of:

    Jeff Boone Realty, LLC
    MLS # 21859991
    Bedroom icon.4 BR
    Bathroom icon. 2 BA
    Square footage icon.1,305 Sqft.
    15 results
    • 1