I have lived in Hamilton County since 1992 and love everything about this area! I have experienced the amazing growth, impressive school ratings and overall quality of life. It is a community I love and support with my time, talents and treasure!
Since selling my first listing in 2004, a lake home in the month of February (they say that ‘never happens’!) to the hundreds of families since then… From that first opportunity, I still believe every home is a privilege to be selected to represent the buyer or seller. A home purchase or sale is the largest financial investment a person or family will make. Whether you are moving because of a job relocation and a long-distance, a renter becoming a first-time homeowner, a new marriage, a growing family, or right-sizing, or investment, my clients are not a 'transaction’. Each situation is unique. You have a story that is just yours. It is a pleasure to be included in that story, in that trust, to be part of your journey from start to closing. It is always my goal to turn clients into friends! The closing is just the beginning…
It is the greatest compliment to be referred to family, friends, co-workers as these relationships grow. I get to help generations of clients – their (adult) kids, the grandparents, friends of family as they grow and have life changes in their housing needs. It truly is a JOY to be a part of these seasons and chapters.
With every closing, I donate to a charity on behalf of my clients. Here is a sampling of those organizations I support:
Scroll to below for reviews from buyers and sellers.
Find the market value of your home compared to
other homes in your area for FREE!
Find the market value of your home compared to other homes in your area for FREE!
I started my home-buying journey with a dream and very little information. From the moment I met Susan, she provided me clear and detailed information about the home-buying process, answered my many questions with prompt and helpful responses, and was even present during the inspection to make sure that my questions were answered and my concerns were addressed. She advocated for me through the negotiations with the seller and ensured that I was informed at each step of the process. She gave me moving boxes and supplies and a "1st night kit" full of essentials that came in handy when I moved. She continues to check in with me to offer information about painters and repairs and ensured that I had completed the necessary forms for my taxes. I am so grateful that Susan was my Realtor and is now my friend.
Selling a home that you have been in for 18 years is an emotional and difficult process. Susan listened well and was attentive to our needs. I could not have gone through this process without Susan by my side. Susan was professional and followed through on every task and reminder. She is highly experienced, detailed oriented, a great communicator, and the list goes on. Finding the right realtor is very important, and we highly recommend Susan Tibbs. Susan went above and beyond our expectations, and we are confident she will do the same for any client she represents.
If you are in the market for a new home, new home build or looking to sell your home, Susan is amazing! Susan is thoughtful, customer-focused, educated and on top of her game. While I am sure she was juggling several clients, we would have never known. Susan was there for us every step of the way with our new home build, guiding us through the process and helping us keep organized with the onslaught of to-do's. Susan also made the sale of our current home seamless and helped us time going to market just right so we wouldn't have to move twice. You can tell Susan is skilled at her craft and cares about what she does and her clients. We appreciated her hard work and help so very much and couldn't have kept up with it all without her! Susan is amazing and I would hire her again and highly recommend her. She truly goes above and beyond for her clients!
Susan has been a great friend of Brent and I for several years. A friend is someone you can trust, but when looking for a realtor, you also want someone who knows the business and
earns it by diligent preliminary work and accurate pricing that happens when listing your home. Susan earned our business.
Susan is an expert stager. We did all the things she suggested form moving furniture to taking all the personal pictures off the wall in order to minimize the clutter. She also offered to share a dining table and a cute table and chairs for the front porch which we were lacking. All these measures gave our home a look that anyone could imagine themselves living in.
The first couple that saw our home on the first day of listing made an offer. With Susan’s help, we negotiated an acceptable price and the house was sold. She continued to help us through the inspection process, assisting with recommendation for repairs, and serving as my power of attorney at closing when I couldn’t be there. Since we were moving out of state, she was also able to refer us to a wonderful realtor in our new community. We would highly recommend Susan as a realtor, she did a fantastic job!
Susan was a wonderful realtor to work with in selling our mom's house after her passing. She made a difficult process much easier for my brother, sister and myself. Susan was extremely professional, and yet with a gentle touch as well. She guided us through the whole process, making sure we understood each step. Susan was always quick to respond to emails and phone calls, and encouraged us to be in touch if we ever had a question. I know who I'll call if I am looking for a home in Indy!
Susan helped make the home-buying process a very positive experience! I learned a lot from Susan and I am very happy with my home! It's like Liam and I are starting a new chapter and it's going to be a great one! I feel like this house represents what I want for Liam, what he deserves, and how hard I will work to give him just that. Thank you so much for all of your help! I really appreciate everything you have done, and I want you to know that you didn't just find our new home, you helped us find our new life."
Susan is a best-in-class professional and I had a great experience during my relocation to Indiana. She goes beyond expectations, always taking care of my family needs and respecting the fact that we are new in the area. Besides business and real estate knowledge, it is important to have someone you can trust during these difficult times. I have already recommend her to a few friends.
• If you are looking for a realtor who will WORK FOR YOU, Susan is your gal. I initially contacted Susan about a listing for a home in the neighborhood I desired. Unfortunately, (or fortunately) that particular home had already sold. That was a year ago. Since that time, and throughout the next months, Susan remained in touch with me. She emailed me listings of homes for sale in that same neighborhood. Knowing how quickly homes were selling on the NE side of Indy, I immediately reached out to her again to inquire about a home. She responded to me immediately and was able to set up a time for me to view the home. This was THE HOME for us; location and price were perfect and EXACTLY what we were looking for. From that moment forward, and every step of the way throughout the home buying process, Susan worked with us quickly to insure my husband and I would own this home. She is the ULTIMATE PROFESSIONAL...prepared, responsive and prompt, knows her stuff and is a true advocate for any home buyer. For example, on the day of closing Susan showed up with a container full of EVERYTHING a new home buyer needs to insure a first nights' stay in your new home. Similarly, after we closed, she remained in touch providing us with recommendations for contractors and provided other important information. My husband and I cannot thank her enough for demonstrating her professionalism! I would highly recommend her to anyone who is serious about buying a home. I can only imagine she would do the same if we were selling a home. In any case, I am forever grateful that I made that first call to Susan. She did not disappoint!
Susan is a great partner and resource when buying and selling a house. She thinks of everything and is thorough, resourceful and fun to work with!
Susan helped my wife and I with the biggest investment of our lives to date: Our first home. The common theme with Susan is she helped us feel at ease and comfortable at all times in the process. She was prompt in each step of the process and proactive with information and ideas. She is detail oriented, an expert in the field, and someone that goes to work each day to help people. Even after the close, Susan is always there to help us with questions we've had as first time homebuyers. If you're looking for a real estate agent that delivers, look no further than Susan Tibbs
Susan came highly recommended to me by my parents. My parents recently relocated to Indy and Susan was recommeded to them by their realtor in Fort Wayne. Susan was so kind to my parents and worked very closely with them and together they found a great house. She is still in contact with them. When I first met Susan to find my house she was extremely prepared and I knew within moments that she is special and I want her on my side. Susan goes way above her job. She is a wealth of information and resources. We found a GREAT house and I still have contact with Susan today. That was a year ago. Susan is one of the finest women I know. Just meet her she is the best investment you could make.
Susan helped us sell our existing home and buy our new home. There aren't enough words to describe how wonderful she is. She is extremely thorough, knowledgeable, motivated, client-advocating, compassionate - this list goes on and on. I wouldn't choose anyone else but her for our future real estate needs!
Susan went above and beyond in helping us sell our house and find our dream home! She never pressured us to make any offers that we were not comfortable with. Her final touches around moving day were so helpful, she made us feel like family! Thanks Susan!
We were introduced to Susan by another friend who used her to find a house and was her agent as well. We loved her at the first meeting and she was so patient with us and did not pressure us into anything we were not qualified to buy. She is kind, thorough, professional, and detail oriented. We will certainly recommend her to anyone we know that needs a home.
We had the pleasant experience of working with Susan Tibbs, both as a buyer and later as a seller. Her professionalism and knowledge of the field of real estate greatly impressed us. She was a pro in all aspects of the processes. Her calm manner and reassurance was top-notch. We would highly recommend her for any of your real Estate needs.
Susan sold our home in a very difficult market. She had names and resources for all the repairs, staging, landscaping and other needs to make our home sale ready. She made the process so much easier for us. She is patient and professional, thorough and competent. She is helping me now to find my next home.
I've had the pleasure of working with Susan staging homes she has listed. Susan's commitment to her clients is unwavering. She is highly professional but cares for her clients as though they were close friends. She stays on top of market trends and goes that extra mile to assure the buyer or seller's end result is what they were hoping for-sometimes even more than that. Putting your home on the market and/or buying a new home can be a stressful experience and choosing the right agent is so important. I've seen her walk first time buyers or those saying good-bye to their lifelong homes through that experience. As a result, I can confidently recommend Susan Tibbs to anyone in need of a real estate agent.
Susan is an excellent realtor with attention to detail. She works hard to meet her clients needs and provides excellent guidance in the buying or selling of your home. She sold our home 2 days after we listed it. We received more then acceptable price for our home. She also assisted in finding a trusted realtor out of state. We were extremely please with Susan and all she did for our selling and buying of our homes.
Susan is an excellent Real Estate Agent! She recently assisted my family with purchasing our dream home! Susan has since then followed up with us to make sure we have everything we need to make owning a home easy. Thank you for all you have done for my family, we are loving being home owners again!
I recently received a job promotion and was tasked to pack up and be in another state in two weeks. I contacted Susan Tibbs right away as I knew I had to get my Condo on the market as soon as possible. She was very helpful in every aspect. It took about a week but we managed to get my Condo ready to go on the market. Since I had sold most of its contents, Susan came over and staged my Condo with her own decorations and furniture…it looked beautiful. Within 5 days we had multiple offers and was able to sell quickly. Since I had to leave the state, I gave Susan Power of Attorney to close the sale for me. She was fabulous and kept me informed every step of the way. Closing went off without a hitch. Susan is the best realtor I have ever had the pleasure of working with. She I kind and courteous and able to think of things that I totally forgot about. This move would not have gone as well as it did if it weren’t for Susan.
Susan Tibbs is a wonderful realtor to work with, both in buying and selling a house. She has been in the real estate business for a number of years and brings a lot of experience. She has resources to assist in the preparation and staging of a home and is very organized in her approach to buying/selling a home. She also has a wonderful personality, is friendly and easy to communicate with.
Susan has been our realtor twice now. She has helped us find 2 different homes and sell one home. She goes above and beyond for her clients. We knew we were in good hands with Susan. She helped us to put our home on the market and received an offer within the same day of listing. She knows what people are looking for and how to make a house show worthy. She held our hand as we then found our new home with her guidance as well. She reached out to other realtors to help us find the home that fit what our needs were. If we had to sell our home again we would use Susan without question. Her knowledge, guidance, and resources have been very helpful and we were blessed to have her help.
Susan was a wonderful realtor, who became a great friend to our family. She was patient, thoughtful, and went above and beyond to help make sure that we chose the perfect house. If you're looking for a real estate agent that cares, call Susan.
Susan Tibbs did an excellent job with the selling of my home. She is very knowledgeable, provided great guidance and recommendations, and always kept me informed.... not to mention she sold my home in 4 days! She also went the extra mile in representing me in my absence, since I was moving out of state during the closing. I strongly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
Susan is wonderful to work with. She was very patient, kind and generous during and after the purchase of my home. I have recommended her to my friends and she will be the first one I call when I am ready to move again!
From my very first time I worked with Susan Tibbs, Susan has displayed extraordinary diligence and knowledge, as well as trustworthy advice in the home-buying process.
She is thorough, patient and understands all of the details involved with purchasing or selling a home.
She does not merely show you houses for sale, but makes excellent and constructive observations that are extremely helpful based on her experience. Her past experience in this business has provided a wealth of knowledge and she is an invaluable part of making the whole process very smooth, comfortable and quite educational!
She always answers questions promptly, addresses concerns without making clients feeling any pressure, and guides her clients through the buying/selling process from beginning to end with ease.
If you are looking to buy or sell a home, I recommend you use Susan Tibbs with F C Tucker because the service she provides is priceless!
“We were referred to Susan Tibbs by family who had successfully worked with Susan before. We had quite the task before us! Finding a new home in Indianapolis while still living in San Francisco! Susan helped us in narrowing down our selections and as we pin pointed the one we thought might be the one -- we flew down to see it. Susan had lined up a very helpful selection of comparable homes to see in one day, that helped us better understand the Indianapolis market and feel confident about our choice! We made an offer. Everything went on smoothly from there on out. Susan is a very professional, organized and knowledgeable real estate agent. We feel very fortunate to having had Susan’s help in finding our next home.” Thank you Susan!
Susan is a highly skilled real estate agent who works exceptionally hard at ensuring your house sale and new home purchase is a smooth process. Not many can compete with her attention to detail and professionalism. She fought for us, made sure we came out ahead and did not let anything slip by unnoticed. Not only is she the best at what she does, she is a wonderful person to work with. She is kind, thoughtful, and always has your best interest in mind. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell or purchase a house.
I have used Susan both personally and referred many clients to her because of her hard work and accessibility, She is experienced and knows exactly how to relate to each client and their situation. I would highly recommend her!
Susan has been my Realtor of choice for many years. A great asset for any home buyer or seller, Susan always goes the extra mile and has a tremendous eye for the details.
I have worked with Susan on the mortgage side and can assure you that she is professional, detail-oriented and always taking care of whatever needs to be done to make the purchase of your new home as smooth as possible. She honestly treats every purchase as though she was helping a family member or friend. I have worked with many realtors over the years and I can assure you that there are not too many out there that work harder than Susan, on behalf of their clients.
I encourage you to trust your real estate transaction to Susan and can guarantee from past experiences, you will receive the absolute best in service and commitment.
Should You Consider a Short Sale or Foreclosure Property?READ MORE
Apple Orchards and Pumpkin Patches in IndianaREAD MORE
The Basics of Investing in Rental PropertiesREAD MORE
Terms and Definitions You Need to Know When Getting a MortgageREAD MORE
Where to Watch the Leaves Change in Indiana, Kentucky and MichiganREAD MORE