Additional Details

Property Details

Lot Dimensions:

132X247

Basement:

Yes

Directions:

GPS Friendly

Tax and Financial Info

Semi-Annual Property Tax:

$1, 890.83

Tax Year:

2026

Quick View

Address:

321 S Main Street New Castle IN 47362 4218

Status:

Active

On Site:

97 Days On Site

Price:

$725, 000

Year Built:

1847

Lot Size:

0.75

County:

Henry County

Township:

Henry

MLS #:

202610186

Property Type:

Mixed Use

Community Information

City:

New Castle

Subdivision:

None

Zip Code:

47362 4218

Rooms

Type	Dimensions	Level
Master Bedroom	2377 x 4138
3rd Bedroom	4 x 2
Den	1 x 4138

Description

Historic presence, bold scale, and the kind of opportunity that rarely comes along, this standout New Castle property delivers it all. Built in 1847 by Mason Livezey for the Eli Murphy family, this two-story structure offers over 4,100 square feet and sits on a hard to find 0.75 acre lot right in the heart of town. From the moment you arrive, the architectural character makes an impression-timeless, substantial, and ready for its next chapter. The heavy lifting has already been done, giving you a strong head start. All five chimneys have been completely rebuilt, a new roof with slate look shingles adds both durability and style, and fresh interior and exterior paint create a clean, refreshed feel throughout. New flooring has been installed, along with new shutters and soffit, while the columns have been reworked to ensure long-term structural integrity, preserving the look while strengthening the foundation for what comes next. And then there’s the feature that truly sets this property apart, its dedicated parking lot. In a downtown setting where parking is often limited, this is a rare and valuable asset that adds everyday convenience and long-term appeal. With its size, history, and extensive updates already in place, this property offers the kind of flexibility and presence that invites creativity. Whether you're envisioning a residential restoration, a business venture, or a blend of both, this is a space with stories behind it, and plenty more waiting to be written.

Source: IRMLS as distributed by MLS GRID, MLS ID: 202610186

Listing provided courtesy of Krista Gibson 765-529-2211 with RE/MAX First Integrity

Last Updated: 5/29/2026 | 3:13 PM

Home Details

Status: Active

Price: $725,000

Address: 321 S Main Street, New Castle, IN 47362-4218

Bedrooms:

Bathrooms: 0

Square Feet: 0

97 days on Site

• Property Type: Commercial
• Built in 1847
• 97 days on Site
• 0.75 Lot Size