Tucker Customer Care, REALTOR®/Broker, F. C. Tucker Company, Inc.
Tucker Customer Care
Additional Phone (317) 954-4768

Cicero Homes for Sale

Homes for Sale in Cicero, Indiana

Cicero, named after the Cicero Creek, was founded in 1834. Located on the north end of Morse Lake, the town is largely a lakeside community. The town grew with the arrival of the railroad in 1859. Residents found employment at flour mills, a steam saw mill, and with the abundance of natural gas, two glass factories. Cicero was the home of the first bridge built in Hamilton County over a major stream, the Cicero Creek.

The bridge was later converted into a covered bridge and painted red. The “Red Bridge” became one of the town’s most memorable landmarks. The red bridge image is still used today as the town’s trademark. The bridge was torn down in the 1950s to make way for the construction of Morse Reservoir, another milestone in the town’s history. The opening of the Morse Reservoir brought a wave of steady growth and development. Cicero is notable for welcoming teenage AIDS activist Ryan White to its community in 1987. White is buried in Cicero.


Cicero Area Homes

State Road 19 runs through Cicero and will take you north to Tipton. Cicero is conveniently located between US Route 31, which takes you to Kokomo, and State Road 37 runs toward Noblesville and Fishers, while I-69 runs further south and leads into Indianapolis. Most residents work in one of these larger communities and find Cicero centrally located. Residents like coming home to the town’s less-rushed atmosphere at the end of a busy day, and they like raising their families in its quiet neighborhoods. Cicero is a blend of original homes and newer suburban homes, offering the amenities of suburban living in the developing areas around Morse Reservoir. Some homes are located on lakefront properties.

Our realtors can help you find a home in this beautiful lakeside community. We work hard to be experts in the local market in order to find a house you can call home. Cicero offers its residents the qualities of a small town with the recreational amenities of the lake and the convenience of being close to the larger communities of Noblesville, Kokomo, and Anderson. Please give us the opportunity to introduce you to this great lifestyle.


Shopping and Dining

There are locally-owned restaurants in Cicero that serve everything from pizza and burgers to steak and seafood. There are also several chain restaurants in town. Enjoy a great breakfast, a quick lunch, a hearty dinner, or late night dining.

Specialty, discount, and general merchandise stores dot the streets of Cicero. Residents can easily shop for their personal and household needs. The closest mall is about six miles away in Noblesville. Hamilton Town Center is an open-air streetscape environment that showcases a diverse mix of shops, restaurants, and entertainment venues. Clay Terrace is about 18 miles away in Carmel. This mall is the first outdoor lifestyle property in Indiana. About 80 stores line the broad sidewalks of Clay Terrace Boulevard.


Culture and Entertainment

Outdoor enthusiasts can visit Cicero Community Park and Red Bridge Community Park and Marina or take a walk around the lake and enjoy the scenery. Cicero is known as a destination for those interested in cycling. Strawtown Koteewi Park is located to the east of Cicero. This 750-acre park includes a canoe launch on the White River for boating and fishing, nature trails for hiking and cycling, equestrian trails for riding, and wetlands and prairies for enjoying nature.


Careers and Industry

The town of Cicero actively promotes existing businesses and works to help business startups. Entrepreneurs are very welcome to open a business in the community. More residents are employed by businesses in the manufacturing industry than any other type of business. Other common industries to this area include construction, finance and insurance, wholesale trade, transportation and warehousing, and educational services.



Hamilton Heights School Corporation includes a primary, elementary, middle and high school.  The schools are located in northern Hamilton County in the town of Arcadia. Three towns make up the corporation: Cicero, Arcadia, and Atlanta. The populace of the corporation is evenly divided between professional, blue-collar, and agriculture industries. Its core values are innovation, community, accountability, respect, encouragement, and excellence.

The primary, elementary, and middle schools offer instruction that match each student’s individual needs. The high school offers an extensive and co-curricular program to meet the diverse needs and interests of students. University and business partnerships highlight the many learning opportunities available to help students prepare for higher education and a competitive workplace. Indiana Academic Standards describe what students should know and be able to do. These standards provide for curriculum and instructional choices at Hamilton Heights School Corporation. The school corporation is committed to providing excellent facilities and technology. Each student is given an iPad which allows for further instructional opportunities.

Hamilton Heights is the home of the Huskies. Students can participate in various sports teams including swimming and diving, basketball, wrestling, baseball, softball, track and field, golf, tennis, football, volleyball, soccer, and cross country. There are also many extracurricular activities to choose from to promote the personal growth of each student.

Tucker Customer Care, REALTOR®/Broker, F. C. Tucker Company, Inc.
Tucker Customer Care
Additional Phone (317) 954-4768
Map Legend