How big are the homes in Monticello?

The average property size in Monticello is 1775.1 sq.ft., the largest being 4724 sq.ft., and the smallest being 352 sq.ft.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are house prices dropping in Monticello?

The house prices in Monticello are indeed dropping at the moment. There has been a decrease in price of $47,332.68. There are several factors that can cause a price drop. Higher mortgage rates, lower demand, prices of comparable properties can all cause the price of a house to drop.

What is the housing market like in Monticello at this time?

The housing market and house prices in Monticello are going down. The average house price is $339,900.00 and the average price per square feet is $231.52 per square foot. At the moment, there are 390 homes listed - 157 active, 23 pending, and 210 sold in Monticello.

What is the most popular place to buy a house in Monticello?

The most popular place to buy a home in Monticello is 801 - Carroll - Jefferson. 801 - Carroll - Jefferson has the most properties listed and appears to have the highest demand.

What is the amount of property taxes you have to pay for a house in Monticello?

The average amount of property taxes you would have to pay for a home in Monticello is $2,035.46. Property taxes are tied to the value of the home - the more expensive the home, the higher the taxes.

How fast are houses listed in Monticello being sold?

Properties in Monticello stay on the market for an average of 96 days. A lower number of days indicates a seller's market, while a higher number indicates a buyer's market.

How often are houses listed for sale in Monticello?

The last home listed in Monticello was 198 minutes ago.

Can you visit houses in Monticello?

Currently, there are 2 open houses available for viewing in Monticello.

What is the most expensive house in Monticello?

The cost of the most expensive home in Monticello is $1,199,990.00. Expensive homes often come with better amenities, larger spaces, and faster appreciation.

What is the cheapest house in Monticello?

The cost of the cheapest home in Monticello is $59,000.00. Buying a cheaper home can keep payments low and leave room for customization.

How old are the homes in Monticello?

The oldest home in Monticello was built in 1860, and the newest in 2026.

Back

Back to Search

See all Images

Active

$488,900

$10,000 on 05/22/2026

4 Beds

3 Baths

3,320 Sq. Ft.

5174 Highland Cove Court, Monticello, IN, 47960-1274

Est. Payments: $0/mo

Residential

Built in 1986

131 days on Site

0.35 Lot Size

Central Air

Gas, Forced Air

Additional Details

Contact Agent

Tucker Customer Care

F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.

(317) 954-4768

Description

Welcome to lake life in Monticello! This 4-bed, 3-bath home on Lake Shafer offers over 3,200 sq ft of space designed for gathering, relaxing, and making memories. Open living areas flow easily for game nights, holidays, and summer get-togethers, while multiple bedrooms give everyone room to unwind. Spend your days on the water and evening...

Source: IRMLS as distributed by MLS GRID, MLS ID: 202605419

Listing provided courtesy of Anthony Cohen 574-707-0075 with Summerland Realty Group, LLC

Last Updated: 6/20/2026 | 1:58 PM

Mortgage Calculator

Loan Price: 0/mo

Price & Interest: 0/mo

Property Tax: 0/mo

Mortgage Insurance: 0/mo

Home Insurance: 0/mo

Down Payment

Home Owner Insurance

/yr

Property taxes

/mo

HOA Fees

/mo

Loan Term (Years)

Interest Rate

Mortgage Insurance

Nearby Similar Listings

$463,900

4 Bds | 3 Ba | 2,106 Sqft

5182 Highland Cove Court...

Summerland Realty Group,...

$755,000

5 Bds | 3 Ba | 4,724 Sqft

5259 E Willow Court, Mon...

Joan Abbott Real Estate...

$436,900

4 Bds | 3 Ba | 1,926 Sqft

2007 Deepwater Loop, Mon...

Real Estate Network L.L....

$111,000

1 Bds | 1 Ba | 834 Sqft

4915 E White Point Drive...

Vogel Real Estate...

$129,900

2 Bds | 1 Ba | 806 Sqft

2406 N West Shafer Drive...

Real Estate Network L.L....

$174,900

2 Bds | 1 Ba | 432 Sqft

2371 Untalulti Dr, D, Mo...

Keller Williams Lafayett...

$100,000

1 Bds | 1 Ba | 443 Sqft

2408 N West Shafer Drive...

Real Estate Network L.L....

$79,900

1 Bds | 1 Ba | 352 Sqft

2410 N West Shafer Drive...

Real Estate Network L.L....

$269,900

3 Bds | 3 Ba | 912 Sqft

2412 N West Shafer Drive...

Real Estate Network L.L....

$599,900

3 Bds | 3 Ba | 3,284 Sqft

2308 N Sullivan Court, M...

Vogel Real Estate...

$599,999

3 Bds | 3 Ba | 3,284 Sqft

2308 N Sullivan Court, M...

Vogel Real Estate...

$1,140,000

7 Bds | 7 Ba | 4,507 Sqft

2636 N Peterson Drive, M...

Real Estate Network L.L....

About the Neighborhood

Norway offers a tranquil living environment characterized by quiet streets and a relaxed atmosphere. The neighborhood primarily features charming single detached homes and townhouses with two or three bedrooms, many built during a significant mid-century building period. Parking is widely accessible, making personal vehicle use convenient for daily errands and dining out. Residents benefit from several nearby restaurant options that add to the local appeal. While the terrain is varied and cycling infrastructure limited, individuals who rely on automobiles will find travel and parking practical throughout the area. Norway presents a peaceful setting that highlights comfort and convenience.

Learn more about

Monticello Market Report

Avg. Days on Market

132

Avg. Price Per Sq. Ft.

234.92

Median List Price

$339,900

Homes Listed

155

Frequently Asked Questions

Contact Agent

Tucker Customer Care

F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.

(317) 954-4768

Schedule a Video Tour

Find your perfect home from anywhere. Schedule a personalized video tour with our expert agents for a real-time walkthrough and answers to all your questions.

Type	Dimensions	Level
Master Bedroom	11 x 13	Basement
2nd Bedroom	11 x 11	Main
3rd Bedroom	11 x 14	Main
4th Bedroom	13 x 14	Basement
Kitchen	9 x 12	Main
Family Room	15 x 19	Basement
Dining Room	10 x 13	Main
Living Room	13 x 21	Main
Den	17 x 21	Basement