Frequently Asked Questions

Are house prices dropping in Monticello?

The house prices in Monticello are indeed dropping at the moment. There has been a decrease in price of $47,332.68. There are several factors that can cause a price drop. Higher mortgage rates, lower demand, prices of comparable properties can all cause the price of a house to drop.

What is the housing market like in Monticello at this time?

The housing market and house prices in Monticello are going down. The average house price is $339,900.00 and the average price per square feet is $231.52 per square foot. At the moment, there are 390 homes listed - 157 active, 23 pending, and 210 sold in Monticello.

What is the most popular place to buy a house in Monticello?

The most popular place to buy a home in Monticello is 801 - Carroll - Jefferson. 801 - Carroll - Jefferson has the most properties listed and appears to have the highest demand.

What is the amount of property taxes you have to pay for a house in Monticello?

The average amount of property taxes you would have to pay for a home in Monticello is $2,035.46. Property taxes are tied to the value of the home - the more expensive the home, the higher the taxes.

How fast are houses listed in Monticello being sold?

Properties in Monticello stay on the market for an average of 96 days. A lower number of days indicates a seller's market, while a higher number indicates a buyer's market.

How often are houses listed for sale in Monticello?

The last home listed in Monticello was 670 minutes ago.

Can you visit houses in Monticello?

Currently, there are 2 open houses available for viewing in Monticello.

What is the most expensive house in Monticello?

The cost of the most expensive home in Monticello is $1,199,990.00. Expensive homes often come with better amenities, larger spaces, and faster appreciation.

What is the cheapest house in Monticello?

The cost of the cheapest home in Monticello is $59,000.00. Buying a cheaper home can keep payments low and leave room for customization.

How old are the homes in Monticello?

The oldest home in Monticello was built in 1860, and the newest in 2026.

Back

Back to Search

How big are the homes in Monticello?

The average property size in Monticello is 1775.1 sq.ft., the largest being 4724 sq.ft., and the smallest being 352 sq.ft.

Schools

High School:

Twin Lakes

Middle School:

Roosevelt

Elementary School:

Meadowlawn

Tax and Financial Info

Semi-Annual Property Tax:

$0.5

Tax Year:

2025

Quick View

Address:

5758 E St Johns Avenue Monticello IN 47960 7881

Status:

Active

On Site:

197 Days On Site

Price:

$399, 900

Bedrooms:

3 Beds

Bathrooms:

2 Full Baths

Sq. Feet:

1, 622

Year Built:

2025

Lot Size:

1.07

County:

White County

Township:

Union

MLS #:

202549082

Property Type:

Site Built Home

Community Information

City:

Monticello

Subdivision:

Meadow Brook / Meadowbrook

Zip Code:

47960 7881

Rooms

Type	Dimensions	Level
Master Bedroom	14 x 15	Main
2nd Bedroom	15 x 13	Main
3rd Bedroom	14 x 12	Main
Kitchen	11 x 8	Main
Dining Room	12 x 8	Main
Living Room	17 x 17	Main

Active

$399,900

3 Beds

2 Baths

1,622 Sq. Ft.

5758 E St Johns Avenue, Monticello, IN, 47960-7881

Est. Payments: $0/mo

Residential

Built in 2025

197 days on Site

1.07 Lot Size

Central Air

Gas, Forced Air

Additional Details

Contact Agent

Tucker Customer Care

F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.

(317) 954-4768

Description

This beautiful new, 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home in the Meadowbrook neighborhood is just steps away from Lake Freeman. Scheduled to be completed in February, it features the Blackthorne floor plan and sits on a spacious 1-acre lot. Property taxes currently reflect vacant land only and will be reassessed upon completion of the home....

Source: IRMLS as distributed by MLS GRID, MLS ID: 202549082

Listing provided courtesy of Cathy Russell 765-497-0700 with @properties

Last Updated: 6/9/2026 | 2:43 PM

Mortgage Calculator

Loan Price: 0/mo

Price & Interest: 0/mo

Property Tax: 0/mo

Mortgage Insurance: 0/mo

Home Insurance: 0/mo

Down Payment

Home Owner Insurance

/yr

Property taxes

/mo

HOA Fees

/mo

Loan Term (Years)

Interest Rate

Mortgage Insurance

About the Neighborhood

Zip Code 47960 offers a tranquil environment characterized by low street noise and a calm atmosphere. This neighborhood features a high number of single detached homes constructed mainly between the 1960s and 1990s, many of which include two or three bedrooms. Essential amenities such as pharmacies are conveniently nearby, supplying staple foods and basic necessities without requiring a lengthy trip. Educational institutions, including both primary and high schools, lie within easy reach. The area supports straightforward vehicle parking and accessibility, making driving practical for daily routines. A selection of local restaurants enhances convenience, providing dining options close to residential areas.

Learn more about

Monticello Market Report

Avg. Days on Market

132

Avg. Price Per Sq. Ft.

234.92

Median List Price

$339,900

Homes Listed

155

Frequently Asked Questions

Contact Agent

Tucker Customer Care

F.C. Tucker Company, Inc.

(317) 954-4768

Schedule a Video Tour

Find your perfect home from anywhere. Schedule a personalized video tour with our expert agents for a real-time walkthrough and answers to all your questions.